Recently, ZY Partners (“ZY”) received a favorable award rendered by the Beijing Arbitration Commission (“BAC”). Acting for a foreign-invested enterprise (the respondent), ZY achieved a complete victory: the arbitral tribunal dismissed all arbitration claims asserted by the claimant, including a claim for damages in the amount of over RMB 10 million. The claimant subsequently applied to the Beijing Fourth Intermediate People’s Court to set aside the arbitral award, and the application was also dismissed by the court. ZY assisted its client in securing a comprehensive win!
Overview
This case concerns disputes arising from a distribution agreement (“Agreement”). Following partial performance, the distributor (the claimant) considered that the supplier (the respondent) had committed multiple breaches and tortious acts, and therefore demanded a refund and compensation for its losses, in an aggregate amount exceeding RMB 10 million. Pursuant to the arbitration clause of the Agreement, the arbitration language is English.
Highlights
The case was highly complex given that the products at issue are American products, both the Agreement and the arbitration language are in English, the evidence involve over thousands of pages of English-language materials, and the parties’ positions are sharply divergent.
Upon being retained, the team systematically reviewed the arbitration application, the evidence, and other voluminous materials, and formulated well-reasoned defense strategies and submissions, focusing on core issues such as the governing law, contract interpretation, whether the respondent had committed any breach, and whether it should bear liabilities for such breach.
The arbitration lasted one year and four months and involved three hearings. Throughout the three hearings, the team conducted every aspect of the proceedings in English, including the defense submissions, cross-examination, oral arguments, and closing submissions. In the face of the tribunal’s intensive questioning and the claimant’s on-the-spot rebuttals, counsel responded point by point with clear factual descriptions and precise legal language, maintaining steady and persuasive professional output at every hearing, and presenting the facts of the case and the client’s position to the tribunal fully and thoroughly.
Drawing on its extensive experience in cross-border dispute resolution, the team submitted, at various stages of the arbitration proceedings, multiple legal documents formatted for the tribunal’s convenient review and use, including the Statement of Defense, the Hearing Statement, the Rejoinder to the Claimant’s Response, the Applicable Legal Provisions, and the Closing Submissions. In the end, the arbitral tribunal adopted the vast majority of ZY’s positions in the award.
In the proceedings for setting aside the arbitral award, the ZY team continued to represent the client. Addressing the factual and legal grounds relied upon by the claimant in seeking to set aside the award, counsel responded in accordance with the law, clearly pointing out that the arbitral award was not subject to any ground for setting aside. The court adopted the team’s submissions and duly dismissed the claimant’s application, thereby safeguarding the authority of the arbitral award.
Significance
The arbitral award was objective and fair, sparing the client from claims exceeding RMB 10 million and restoring the confidence of the client and its shareholder in China’s business environment.
ZY possesses extensive experience and proven capability in handling complex cross-border disputes. We are committed to providing clients with dispute resolution legal services of international standard, safeguarding clients’ legitimate rights and interests through professional judgment and a pragmatic approach. The successful representation in this case once again attests to ZY’s professional excellence and strength in the cross-border dispute resolution area, and serves as another example of successful collaboration within our cross-border team.
The case was led by Partners Deng Huiqiong (Starry) and Jing Xin, and jointly represented by Attorneys at Law He Guangming and Shi Tingfeng. Senior Foreign Counsel Mr. Aaron D. Hurvitz provided professional support throughout the proceedings.
![]() | Deng Huiqiong (Starry) Partner/Attorney at Law TEL: 010-58790066-222 Email: huiqiong.deng@zypartners.com |
![]() | Jing Xin Partner/Attorney at Law TEL: 010-58790066-205 Email: xin.jing@zypartners.com |
![]() | He Guangming Attorney at Law TEL: 010-58790066-238 Email: guangming.he@zypartners.com |
![]() | Shi Tingfeng Attorney at Law TEL: 010-58790066-209 Email: tingfeng.shi@zypartners.com |
![]() | Aaron D. Hurvitz Senior Foreign Counsel Attorney at Law (California) Email: aaron.hurvitz@zypartners.com |








Back